2008 AADL Downtown Branch Renovation and Fifth Avenue Parking Survey Comments
Select a category below to view comments from the survey.
Environmentally Friendly is Important (152 Responses)
Improved Pick-up and Drop-off Request and Ideas (47 responses)
Youth, Children, Teen Issues (123 responses)
Teen Behavior (4 responses)
Improve Teen Space and Programs (25 responses)
Better Access for Disabled Persons (59 responses)
Ensure Natural and Adequate Lighting (32 responses)
Mixed Responses on a Café Option (41 responses)
Entry Ideas/Input (25 responses)
Mixed Input on Meeting and Performance Space (53 responses)
Technology Needs/Input (77 responses)
Provide Larger, Clean Rest Rooms (56 responses)
Include a Green Space (28 responses)
Ensure the Inclusion of Quiet Spaces (33 responses)
Input on Furnishings (37 responses)
Input on Building Style and Architecture (50 responses)
Improve Signage (41 responses)
Physical Space - General (215 responses)
Focus on Collections and Core Mission (296 responses)
Minimize Costs (81 responses)
I Love My Library (65 responses)
Is the Renovation Necessary? (77 responses)
General Concerns about Safety (66 responses)
Concerns about Loitering and Library Use By Individuals Who are Homeless (67 responses)
Input on Services - General (269 responses)
Miscellaneous (286 responses)
Environmentally friendly is important (152 Responses)
"green" energy efficient building,
Any new work should be LEED certified in keeping with the City's commitment to environmental responsibility.
If it could be "green" that would also be good.
"Also I think building ""green"" is paramount. Not only because it is the right thing to do today, but because it saves money and resources in the long run. "
"As for question 8, If renovation or new libary takes place- could we please utilize earth friendly ""green"" materials and employ crews that reside in our state - especially with our economy - use our resources, employ our residents. Be the example for our children. Choose interactive art that is engaging to all ages. Act Locally, think Globally."
"Building green is important. "
"Green' building, i.e., fewest possible off-gassing materials, recycled materials, passive solar heating and cooling, etc."
"Green" building standards
"Green" design.
"green" design: eco-friendly materials, no-VOC paints, green roof, etc. etc.
"Green" roof, perhaps solar panels to help with electrical costs, larger restrooms
"green"/environmentally friendly principles such as water efficient bathrooms, passive solar design, green roof, solar panels, etc.
"""sustainable & green"" practices used in every phase of development, construction, materials used, waste disposal/recycling, etc. Make the downtown library a model of ""best green practices!"" Also use ""self-check-outs and self-payment- stations"" in lobby and youth departments, for people to self-serve."
1.More natural light and skylights for energy saving, 2.Solar energy for heating. lighting and water heating, 3. We should try to build the library as green and environmentally friendly as possible.
A green roof -- it not only would have potential environmental and economic benefits of great consequence but also would serve as a model and a reminder of sound environmental practices.
Aesthetically pleasing design and materials, use of recycled building materials. Malletts Creek and Pittsfield branches are good examples.
Also, you didn't ask about "green" ness-I think Mallett's creek is cool(although too small) b/c so much of it is energy efficient. Then a renovation amost seems worthwhile. Otherwise, why not put it into more books and better salaries or hiring more staff?
An ecologically sound building with some great art/sculpture would be great.
An environmentally sensitive building educates our children and expresses our community values; a beautiful building enhances civic pride and displays Ann Arbor's bibliophilic nature. Why not use this opportunity to create a green space, a town commons, over the new parking lot?
bottle recycling at entrances
By all means, keep it green! I love the architecture of Mallett's Creek and Pittsfield but would also be willing to sacrifice expense for environmentally friendly (energy efficient ) spaces. That's more important than texture.
Consideration of energy efficient and "green" building design and construction practices.
Context sensitive building design which will blend with surrounding neighborhood. LEED standards for green building certification - the Mallets Creek and Pittsfield branches are excellent!
Demonstrations of energy efficiencent designs such as green roof visible from inside the library. Storm water detention in rain garden, solar hot water with educational display showing how it works and how much energy it saves. Photovoltaic systems with educational displays.
design should be energy efficient and use renewable energy sources whenever possible
Don't go for LEED certification. You can build a "green" building without the certification and save money
Eco-friendly
Eco-friendly, use of recycled products, etc.
Ecological impact: use visible and innovative energy conservation to publicly show off good design ideas.
energy conservation, quick and easy check out of materials.
energy efficiency
Energy efficiency and environmentally friendly features throughout
energy efficiency in lighting, & HVAC and water use
Energy efficiency, recycling program, post consumer recycled materials, low environmental impact!
Energy Efficiency. Energy Efficiency. And Energy Efficiency. This building MUST be LEED certified to avoid the expense of another renovation a few years down the road when we can't afford 1930s style energy consumption.
Energy efficiency. We should strive for a "passive" building. See: http://www.nature.com/news/2008/080402/full/452520a.html
energy efficient
Energy efficient light bulbs and solar panels. Eco-friendly or green renovation would be great.
"energy use (heating/cooling & lighting), water use in the building and impervious surfaces (roof and surrounding pavements),
natural materials and indoor air quality"
Environmental design/implementation, in line with branch library facilities.
Environmental impact of design and materials is more important to my family than all of these other factors.
environmental issues; the evolution of technology i.e. keeping in mind that technology will continue to improve when budgeting, perhaps less in quantity to allow the library to keep up with quality
environmental soundness and sustainability
environmentally friendly building materials and design
Environmentally friendly reconstruction would be a real plus!
environmentally friendly, energy saving, water conserving, native plants in landscaping
Environmentally friendly.
Environmentally-friendly sustainable design.
Environmentally-sound and protective practices for construction, energy-use and space are very important. (p.s. you have "accommodations" misspelled in #9)
Finally, this is probably a given, but making the building as "green" as possible is important (i.e. LEED certified if possible). To me that includes the public green space idea above.
Focus on environmentally friendly/low-impact materials & design.
Green awareness everywhere possible. Library is where smart people go..we expect smart things and can teach others!Ha!
Green Building (LEED)
Green building elements
Green building materials and energy use.
green building using natural light and recycled materials. look at the new skyline high school
green building/green design
Green design
Green design
Green design and construction.
Green design features to save money and the environment: more natural light, reclaimed materials (if possible), pedestrian- and bike-friendly, efficient heating/cooling systems, LEED certification, etc.
Green Design for sustainability: LEED certification.
Green design! this includes NOT catering to drive-in customers. Make pedestrian/bike access welcoming and easy. Make auto access not so easy - I don't want to subsidize more drivers in our downtown when we have such good public transit and a walkable community.
green engineering and decorating
Green Pro-enviroment
Green roof (similar to Mallet Creek)
GREEN, ENERGY EFFICIENT DESIGN. Passive and active solar power, green energy purchases. Perhaps aesthetically pleasing windmills on the roof.
Green, sustainable design and build
Green/LEEDS/Energy Star compliant design.
Highlight green design elements
Hopefully it will be constructed with materials that would care for the environment. It would be great if we also help making the renovated library an example and tool to educate people how to start thinking and eventually take action to be green. If we use materials that are environmentally friendly then renovating/redesigning the Downtown Library will be for a much better cause.
I hope as much as possible the new design will incorporate "green" elements and sustainable energy (solar, wind, occupancy light switches, etc., run off control)
I think it would be great to use as many recycled and renewable resources to build the addition, and perhaps a "green" roof as well. We visit at least once a week! Can't wait! thanks for all your hard work.
I think maybe making it more green would be nice. Like skylights to reduce energy used on lighting.
I think the building needs to be designed to be energy efficient and showcase materials and design strategies that are easy on the environment. I would love to see key building features highlighted in educational displays so that the building itself can be a tangible lesson for our community of smart choices in building design.
I think the building should be as "green" as possible, i.e., built in an environmentally responsible way.
"I think the Downtown Library need go (green) as possible, having teaching,on how to preserve our (environment) for the future."
I think the Library is adequate and if changes must be made I think green technolody for heat and light should be on the top of the list not "color and varied textures" or "download i-tunes stations", There is not a single question on this survey about use of LED lighting or geothermal heat....instead you want to use the underground space for parking......
I would like to see an eco friendly approach to the remodel. More solar energy and heat useage. Like the Pittsfield branch
I would like to see as many environmentally-friendly construction and renovation practices and products as possible.
I would like to see green building principles incorporated into the renovations as much as possible.
I would like to see it be as eco-friendly as possible.
I would like to see the library go way out there on the environmental side, like very low energy consumption, LEED platinum rating, etc.
I would like to see the renovation make use of green building materials and concepts, with special emphasis on energy efficiency and renewable energy sources. Public buildings offer a unique opportunity to demonstrate green building concepts, to save the public money in the long run, and to give the public a view of what is possible. Bearing this in mind, conservation of resources and avoiding unnecessary building would be an important part of making the project environmentally responsible.
I would love to hear that environmentally friendly technology is being implimented in the design and construction of the new Library.
I would recommend the environmental friendly renovation. It will save money in the long-term and good for an environment. (e.g. energy efficient lights, composite toilet, garden on the roof, recycled materials)
I'd like to see the main branch of the AADL live up to the green standards set by their newer branches. The library has an incredible breadth of collection but I think much of that is lost and buried in the dull, full stacks. The main building should match the excellence of the branches and website.
I'd really like to see the new downtown library be LEED certified or otherwise incorporate environmentally friendly and energy conserving practices in the new building. Ann Arbor is a progressive city, and it is important for new city buildings to set the standard for environmental stewardship in Ann Arbor.
If changes are made to the library, please be considerate that with all renovations and redesigning, there is a strong impact on the using of energy and material resources.
If decide to make any renovations, must use GREEN thinking approach.
If there is a full service cafe, then it should not use disposable cups, spoons, plates, etc. It should only have re-usable. If nothing else, the library should be sustainable. After all, libraries are about education and the latest information- so the latest information should be used to keep the building green and sustainable. Finally some incentive should be in place to encourage people to bike, walk,or take the bus to the library. Thank you.
If you rebuild--REBUILD GREEN. Save money.
Incorporating as many "green" features to the new facility (like Mallet's Creek) as possible.
It should be as energy efficient as the budget will allow.
It should represent Ann Arbor as a Green town, connected to the environment and outdoors.
It will bring in more value if the facility is supporting the 'green' effort (i.e. energy-efficient, eco-friendly materials, etc.)
It would be good to use the roof for either solar power or a green garden space or both.
It'd be nice if it was built with a consideration of ecological issues (like Mallet's Creek). Also, above I didn't really have opinions on many issues so I just indicated these as "1s".
keep it GREEN and simple
Keep the renovations and new library as "GREEN" as possible. That will be a great way to show that Ann Arbor is dedicated to positive change.
LEED Certification (use of recycled/sustainable materials, passive/solar HVAC, super high-efficiency electonics, etc.).
LEED design.
let's go green! as eco-friendly as possible is important to me in the development of new public buildings! thanks!
Like the waterless urinals, I suspect you're already looking at cutting edge implementation of "outside of the box" utilities. I'm mainly wondering if daylight "tubes/enhanced skylights" could be used instead of electricity, weather permitting, and if there have been any studies done on what colors of lights enhance a quiet, studious mood, and possibly having those colors of lights in their respective areas throughout the library (i.e., one color for the entryway, a different one (ones?) for the cafeteria, and still others for various other sections, as appropriate...).
Low energy use building design.
Make building energy efficient & eliminate toxic building materials (including computers) as much as possible
Make environmental sustainability a central focus in the renovations/improvements.
Make it as "green" a building as possible. This makes financial and environmental sense and it becomes a public model for new technology.
make it as green as possible
Make it 'green' - use of solar panels and/or passive solar heating
Make it green and inviting (Malletts Creek and Pittsfield branches are excellent examples -- both of these facilities are outstanding)
Make the building look nice from the outside. Nothing way "out there" - just pleasing to the eye. It should also be as "green" as possible.
Make this building energy efficient and use sustainable design criteria.
Makes it as GREEN as possible (environmentally sound).
More eco-friendly library (fluorescent lights, blow dryers, etc.)
More Green/clean energy. I would like to see the Library be 100% self sustained for water and energy and recycling
natural, eco-friendly, and sustainable building materials and practices.
Needs to be as energy efficient as possible.
Options for recycling of stuff that patrons bring into the library (paper, water bottles, etc.)
Please continue to follow the examples you have set for green architecture with the Mallets Creek and Pittsfield branches.
Please do everything to make the renovation as environmentally friendly as possible. Composting toilets, for instance, would be great.
Please make the renovation LEED certified! Environmental impact is very important. The new branch libraries are awesome.
Possibily more environmental energy options.
Recycling events or in house receptacles
Recycling stations for patrons and staff
some eco-friendly addtions like solar panels, geothermal heat, etc. would be good
Sould be energy efficient. Architecture Should be unique - not just an uninteresting structure like some downtown buildings. Thanks.
susainable desing is EXTREMELY important. The most sustainable building is one that is already built. Transform the exisiting library instead of creating more landfill by demolishing it. Be green!
sustainability - continue your fantastic efforts; perhaps geothermal heat?
sustainability, conservation of resources,
Sustainable building using natural materials from renewable sources.
sustainable design (active and passive solar, energy/water conservation, etc; integrated into a public education function about sustainability and climate change).
sustainable materials and design
Sustainable materials throughout.
Switching to a grass roof; using solar panels; installing rainbarrels and creating a rain garden, with attendant signs explaining the process to the public
Take advantage of Daylighting. Make the building LEEDs appropriate.
The last time the Downtown Library renovated, I couldn't enter for 2 years. Like a small but growing group of people, I have multiple chemical sensitivity, and the off-gassing of the carpets, paint, and vinyl made me extremely ill. It did help when I became able to request items online to be held, which shortened the amount of time I had to be in there. So a BIG priority for me would be "green" building materials (especially paints and carpets, and materials free from formeldehyde - sp?).
The library is conveniently located by the main bus station. I would like a new or renovated library to meet "green" standards to decrease energy consumption, improve water conservation, etc.
The use of recycled materials and "green" building methods as much as financially possible.
Thinking about "green" buildings and sustainability.
This is a great opportunity to embrace "green" building methods/materials AND educate the public about their use! Let's create an environmentally friendly library that is an example of environmental design! That is SO relevant to our times and to current public concerns!
This library should have all the LEAN building and GREEN technology incorarated into it's design,with the explanations or directions on where to learn about wind power or photovoltaics right at hand.
To make it energy efficient
Try and make it a LEED desginated building.
Try to be as green as possible, espeically green setbacks with space enough for trees to mature to provide maximum ecosystems resources.
use as much "green" technology as possible or reasonable.
Use environmentally sound design techniques, such as naturally lighting to reduce need for artificial lighting and natural air ventilation to reduce HVAC operations.
Use green technology.
Use of "green" elements. Make the library a green building and use as many sustainable materials as possible.
use of 'green' building materials and high-efficiency lights, faucets, HVAC
Use of solar energy, and solar light tubes, and green building materials. Possible use of geothermal system for heating and cooling. Maybe use a roof garden to minimize solar thermal effect in the summer time like shown at the Matthaei Botanical Garden.
Utilization of some of the green building materials would be well received here in Ann Arbor as well as incorporating more cost effective heating and cooling.
Improved Pick-up and Drop-off Request and Ideas (47 responses)
value the outside book drop's placement because I can use it when I'm on bike without taking my child out of the bike trailer; I would like to see a similar setup on any new building.
A drive-through window for PICKING UP reserved books, etc as well as for returns.
A drive-through book return would be great!
A drive-through drop box would be extremely nice for people who want to drop of books and videos on their way to work.
A drive-through drop off of to return library materials would be a great addition!!
A drive-up book return would be GREAT!!
A proper drop off area for cars.
Ability to drop off material with out paying for parking or blocking traffic
Also would love to see a drive thru drop off and pick up window for ordered books/material - this could be coincide with a drive thru coffee/pastry window. very convient for the mom with kids in car seats and typical Michigan weather.
Also nice to have is "drive by drop off" of materials that need to be returned without having to go inside the building.
An auto drop-off would be very convenient.
An easier book drop-off area that's not a main street, and preferably one that's easily accessible by car (this is one of the main reasons I am very happy using the Pittsfield branch instead).
Continued options for short-term parking to drop off books or check out just a few books
Convenient book drop off,
Don't worry about drive-thru. If patrons are going to return materials by car, they can drive to a branch.
Drive through pick up of reserved materials.
DRIVE UP BOOK RETURN STATION FOR NO PARKING EXPENSE
Drive-thru book return is the single most important feature I would like to see at all branches.
Drive-Up Book and AV Materials Drop off please!
Drive-up drop box should be able to be reached w/o leaving the car. It is impossible for disabled users to easily drop books in the drop box where it is currently located.
drop box efficiency for the employees.
Drop-off facility set back from a public street and out of the traffic line.
Easy and free parking space for short term pick up's or dropp off's
easy drop off drive through access. Thanks!
easy drop off of books for cyclists/walkers (as good as it is now)
Easy patron drop off and pick up. I think you've covered all my needs.
Fast surface parking to pick up or drop off books is the most important issue.
good book drop off drive up station is very important improvement that could be made
Have the drop off area for people be out of the street traffic.
Having an easier way to drop off donated books rather than having to take them to the loading dock.
I especially think a patron drop-off area is important. Drivers should be severly ticked when stopping on Fifth; its dangerous for those getting in and out as well as other drivers.
I really appreciate the "5-minute drop-off" parking spot on William. Keep something like that, please! Also, this survey didn't ask about the audio-visual collection: I love the DVD selection and would appreciate a broader books-on-CD selection.
I think having a safer drop off station - if having a new library is a good idea as well as a safe drop off and pick up spot for kids and elders. I've noticed stopping on 5th ave near the intersection is dangerous. Theres always accidents happening there.
In order for people to take books out, you must provide a way to return them easily from a free drive up drop off.
"It is vital to have a drive thru book drop, where you don't have to get out of the car. This helps the elderly, handicaped and mothers with small children......also great when it is snowing."
it would be nice to have a drop off for book return so you don't have to park and walk to the box.
It's really time for a convenient drive through book return.
Longer "drop off" time than 10 minutes in the adjacent lot would be worth pursuing.
Make sure there is free parking for drop offs and for picking up material quickly. Make request pick up an easy in easy out free experience!
Most important is a drop off solution for people who insist on stopping in a driving lane of a busy street. A pull in on the street or an arrangement of some kind with the parking lot people - but that would have to be well publicized!
Passenger drop-off/pick-up and drive-through book drop are needed, even if a whole new library is not.
place to return books from one's car, like the drop off mailboxes at the post office
Some quick free 5 min parking for book pickups at the circulation desk.
the amount of car fumes that any waiting/loading/unloading area will create.
The parking and roadside drop-off have both been adequate for me.
The thing that bothers me the most at the moment is no place to drop off/pick up on 5th. If parking is underground, drive through book drop off will be very important.
Your drop off box is inconvenient
Youth, Children, Teen Issues (123 responses)
Also, having adult book areas on the same floor as the youth area would be nice. Perhaps a system of calling the book from the adult area and having it sent to the youth area-it is difficult to take small kids to the adult area-my kids made too much noise and disturbed adults while also causing me to take the stroller and everything to another floor-this is not very condusive to families at the library.
Children's and young peoples spaces and services are important because we must encourage them to read and appreciate learning.
A engaging and well designed children's area, close to the youth/teen area will make family visits more possible, and mom can keep track of everyone. Cafe with healthy offerings will decrease hunger-related melt downs.
A good children's area close to adults area is also key, so parents can puck up pooks and bring children into the kids area. Having a couple baby sitters for a nominal fee would be great too.
A large childrens space to ensure local families can engage their children in the Library at a young age
A more comfortable teen space. Possibly have brigh colored couches, rugs etc.
A no children allowed section adults only .Sometimes it is hard to read with small children and babies around.
A play space that is seperate for young children so that they can be noisy and not disruptive to others that are using library manners.
Also, I like the idea of the "corral" that the West branch has for young children. Just a short wall to confine small children in the kids section would be very helpful. I never felt like my child would be wandering aimlessly at West branch becuase he was in the kids section which is somewhat jpartitioned off.
an area which can be 'closed off' for young toddlers/children is very important to me (and my usage of the library)
Anything that attracts young children would be welcomed.
Appreciate play area for young children
"As a bi-lingual parent trying to raise a bi-lingual child, I wish the children's section accomodated this better. Currently I can't find Spanish language board books because they are not cataloged and I just have to read through all the titles while occupying a 15 month old. I wouldn't mind some of the renovation $$ being put towards a greater selection of children's books in Spanish language and perhaps the multi-lingual section having a more 'inviting' presence. Other than that I am generally happy with the children's area, which I use most. The fish tank is a hit, and the toys are also great.
I am considering home-schooling my child in a few years but would not even consider this without the excellent resources and support of the community library."
As the mother of two young children, I think the children's room in the downtown library is very spacious and welcoming. It does not, in my opinion, need to be expanded. It is large enough to give kids space to talk and play without disturbing anyone who wants silence in the library. I think the organization of materials could be clearer, with better signs. Even though I am a librarian, I find that materials are not easy to find in the library (!) or to describe to anyone else how to find -- the organizational system is a bit too complex (fiction separated by size/content [chapter books, picture books, what's the "e" about], non-fiction separated into various areas, folktales with dewey decimal numbers in another area, so many compartments and none ever actually explained! Redoing the organizational system to some degree, while not about the building, would make the library more usable.
Audio video set up room for presenting info to first time patrons especially for grade school children. Make the library friendly to children. get input from children how to properly use the internet and computers
baby friendly spaces
Better children's library.
Bussis like, but also a setting where teens don't feel like their about to get yelled at for breathing, a cross inbetween.
Check out at the children's room would be great. Lists of suggested reading for different grades would be great (see Newton, Mass, lists for reference).
Children & teen spaces are important but they are already great and don't need to be improved (speaking as the parent of both elementary & middle-school aged children).
Children/family and teen programs are the main draw to the library. Creating a welcoming, safe environment for these activities is key and will bring more people downtown.
Children's area could be improved (Highland Park, Illinois has great - kid and parent friendly atmosphere).
children's room should be designed so that it's easier for parents to keep an eye on their toddlers/preschoolers while they themselves search for books
Coat rack in the Youth Department. Perhaps other areas as well.
Concentration on young childrens' interactive area for discovery and learning. If we capture the childrens' interest early they will be patrons for life
Consider that not everyone using the library has children. I think it's important for the library to be a welcoming space for children, but I'd definitely like a quiet space too.
considering the financial situation of the city as a whole I think the space should be functional and certainly provide for use by children and teens, but glitz , frills, etc. only in so far as they pay for themselves there are so many other needs the city also has.
Continued classes and workshops for toddlers and children.
"
Definitely consider outdoor space, and for the children's area, a good mother's room with changing facilities. "
Do not feel library space should be used to the extent it is for children play etc. Fine for the satellite branches- but down town a more "business" library.
Don't overload the children and teen areas at the expense of adults.
enclosed children's area for safety and noise reasons
Finding more ways to attract and interest children.
For the smaller kids should be easy to use a footstool or ladder near the shelves. So they could better choose by themselves the books/DVD´s.
Going to the public library is a weekly outing for us; it's something my children really look forward to. That said visiting the main branch is my children's least favorite. I'm not really sure why, but perhaps it's that the feel of the children space is not very inviting
"
Have in the children's area space for moms to read to children, perhaps comfy, adult-sized chairs"
"
Having the youth area more secure, to prevent run-away toddlers and preschoolers. Perhaps a gated area."
How about a wing in the downtown library that is made for loud patrons like little kids and teens? When you go anywhere in a college library, there's always a spot for socialites. And it's mutually beneficial for the librarians and for the families who bring their somewhat loud patrons to commune and study.
I am a aregular user and am very happy with the current children's area. The open space for kids to gather is great and the staff make it wonderful. Always suggesting great books and teaching older kids how to use the catologue to find their favorite books.
I am not a high end user of the library but think the current library is nice and functional. Regarding children programs- I personally would rather use the outlying library spaces for kids programs than take children downtown and if I was going to take children downtown close, convenient, safe parking would be VERY important.
I appreciate having the children's department separate from the main library. I would encourage similar design. Allowing children not to disturb quit patrons.
I believe it's important to have areas for children and teen activities.
I didn't comment on the sections for younger users because I don't know.
I don't know about youth needs.
I feel more comfortable bringing my small children to the downtown library because it has a separate children's area where the kids are safe and contained, and are free to be a little noisy. I DO NOT like going to the new branches where the kids' area is open to the rest of the library. I feel that we have to rush to get out before they get too wild. I like the downtown branch because they have a space to play as well as look at books, and we can hang out there for a while. It makes going to the library much more a regular part of our lives.
I have a teenager and I love the teen space. I don't think it needs to be larger but I think having a seperate teen area is good
I have found the current children's area quite adequate. A welcoming, "special" place for my kid from toddlerhood to age 12.
I have lived in Ann Arbor since for most of my life and have always loved the downtown Library. My family always visited every Saturday during my childhood and I continue to visit on on a regular basis. In your rennovations, please keep the dollhouse and similar unique features. I still visit the children's area to look at the dollhouse and never get bored of it, even as an adult. I also love the local art often displayed in the lower level auditorium and the art hanging in the stairwell. Some of my best childhood memories are inside the downtown branch (before and after the 1980's rennovations), and I hope that other children are able to experience such a friendly atmosphere.
I just feel that the children's department needs to be organized and easily accessible for children, with a place for story times etc.
I like how it is currently very welcoming to little people. The layout helps the little ones navigate as though it's their space...creating a love of library for years to come:) FYI--we just moved from Ann Arbor where we lived for two years...
I like the current childrens' room. Is a larger teen room needed? I don't see a problem with lighting or seating as is. I use the Mallet's branch most of the time.
I like the meeting area in the children's section for elementary school classes to gather for field trips to the library. Please include a similar space in a re-designed Downtown Library.
I love Ann Arbor's library off scio church drive -- my only complaint is that the kids' area bleeds into quiet areas -- it's too loud for a library. I hope that the downtown location avoids this problem and keeps the kids area appropriately separate.
I love the fish tank in the children'a area
I think a dedicated children's space makes sense for several reasons. I believe adults and teens would enjoy using the same space. Separateness is a fad that will vanish, don't buy into it.
I think a library should a wonderful adventure for all people of all ages which is focused on books and reading, but it should not be a noisy playland. The new libraries are too loud, and have become a dumping ground for young children who haven't been taught to be quiet when spending time in a library.
I think that the most important function of a public library is to attract children and teens and help them learn to learn and love to learn.
I think the "face out" display works best in the children's area.
I think the automated checkout areas in the children's section need to be better integrated. Right now it feels like you're approaching the librarian and disturbing her work in order to check out books. I think that a better seating space for story hour is critical to continuing to attract all the kids and parents who would like to attend. Due to day cares attending, large groups crowd out stay at home Moms who bring one or two children.
I think the children's section is already wonderful.
I think the library needs to be a welcoming place for kids, not just in the kids area, but throughout the library. Even though my kids are still toddlers, I would like them to feel comfortable and know the entire building and to feel that the entire building is for them, while respecting quiet areas. So when it comes time for them to actually use more of the library, they will be veterans and they will think of the library as the first place to go for their media needs.
I wish the computer areas were more separate in the children's section. (It is always a struggle to keep my kids away from the videos - we have none at home - and keep them focused/enjoying other aspects of the library.)
I would like to see more child-friendly areas for story tellers and workable computers.
I would like to see preshool non-fiction highlighted to encourage its use. I bring grandchildren to your wonderful storytimes. Safety and a friendly environment are my most important concerns.
I'd like to see an area reserved for school children who need to use the library computers for homework. It is very difficult to get on any of the computers in the branches and they are mostly used by adults. it would also be nice to have these homework computers in a low traffic area with a library supervisor or volunteer present at all times to maintain the quiet homework environment and ensure proper use of the computers and sites being visited. It may sound like a lot to ask for but we only have one computer at home and 4 people trying to use it, there have been several times we would have gladly taken our daughter to the library for computer use regarding homework but found it frustrating and not helpful or available.
It would be great if the children's areas (especially any open meeting/play space) were somewhat self-contained to help parents keep their children in the intended areas and to keep them from disturbing adults who are trying to read quietly. My family *loves* the Pittsfield branch's play area. However, the layout at Pittsfield makes it very difficult to contain young children. They're always running from the ball display to the playroom, etc. and their voices tend to carry.
It would be great if there were a designated snack area in the children's department.
Just some general comments on the questions and my responses... I think it's great that the library is thinking seriously about expanding the youth and teen areas, because a love of books and learning and reading has to start young.
keep Youth Dept on first floor
Larger gathering space for children's programs such as story time, crafts, playgroups.
Lots of natural light: windows; color. Lots of face-out books, ESPECIALLY in the children's section, where they really need to be drawn in by the books' covers. Large children's section with comfy seating for both adults and kids (adults to read to kids). Fewer computer/game stations in the children's section. Maybe none at all! Once games were introduced into the children's dept, most kids quit browsing the stacks of books and went straight to play games. I hated it when my own kids would gravitate to uneducational games rather than looking for books! It sabotages the visit -- so many of these kids can play games at home, but they can't check out new books at home -- and if they DON'T play video games at home, maybe it's because their parents don't value the games -- all the more reason to restrict Arthur and all the other games.
Make sure it is child friendly - they are your customers and financial supporters of the future and you want them to have positive associations with the library.
make sure you keep that dollhouse, it was my favorite part of the whole library when i was little
Make the library enviroment a pleseant place for our younger people so they feel the need to use the facitity. Education is the key to our future and the library is a very big part of that future.
many children, now older, have fond memories of the childrens room as it is. Please dont fix what isnt broken!
More windows for the children's section, with view of greenspace--and we love the fishtank!
My family's favorite features are the play area in the youth department and the public garden.
My main concern is that young children have a bright, up-to-date, engaging place to read and learn so as to encourage reading from a young age. This is so very important in today's high-tech, fast-paced world. Additionally, I'd really like to see more helpful library staff. I often feel, when I'm there with my children, that there's no one around - I feel isolated. I don't know if this is due to the current layout of the downtown library or not, but there needs to be a "face" of the AA library to make it a welcoming, accessible place to be.
Note that the population of school-age (and younger) children is dropping at present, not growing. More space for kids is not needed, and who knows what kind of space might be needed in 10 or 15 years when that age group will grow again. Don't spend a lot of money on this.
One of the most frustrating things for me about coming to the library is when child guests "run wild" and disturb me. Seeing more dedicated and sectioned-off children's areas would definitely be an improvement for me. Also, more "quiet areas" for adults only would help as well.
One thing I really like about the present downtown library and would hate to see changed is the relatively small entrance and exit to the children's room. For parents with toddlers and kids who run away, it is much less anxiety promoting to know that there is only one entrance and exist that they must patrol if their kid gets away from them. An "open plan" children's section, like those in many of the branch libraries, is really a challenge to visit for parents with younger kids. The other benefit of an enclosed Children's room is that parents don't have to worry as much about disturbing adult patrons with the noise their child might make.
One thing that I think about every time I go to the downtown library (which is about twice a week) is that I wish there was some sort of gate/door to the children's area. When you have toddlers it's easy for them to just wander out into the main library, a simple door/gate would help deter wandering feet. I understand that parents need to be with their children in the children's area, but it would be an easy way to avoid very loud tantrums.
Our children have always loved the large fish tank, I hope you'll keep that type of thing, too.
Perhaps young children are best served at branch locations.
Personally I feel sorry for smaller children who have to accomodate their parents to the library, so why not consider a non echo architecture to make it less stressful for all who use the library in relation to a "dedicated `quiet` area?
Personally, I would like to see the children computers (not the catalog ones) in the Youth Dept. removed. There are too many little children who associate the library with playing computer games, and not with reading. I think the library should encourage reading from books. The computers are fine for when the children are older and really reading (age 10 or so), but not at the pre-school/kindergarten age.
Play area for toddlers and activities to get them engaged in the library experience while they are young. The Pittsfield Branch has the wonderful Hands On Museum display with the balls, venturi, and vacuum. Kids love it! The play area is great too!
Please acccommodate Strollers in your design and layout. We live walking distance and have 3 children. We would come down with a double stroller (not double wide) But please consider strollers with layout. Also kid areas should have bathrooms VERY close by and include Diaper changing station at a minimum. Possibly family restroom where a stroller could be taken RIGHT into a single bathroom. An extra bonus would be kid height toilet and sink like Briarwood and Toys R Us have but I know that is a lot to ask. It would be AWESOME to have a kids area where a young baby/toddler could be "contained" - a crawler could be without getting near books and pulling books down.
Please consider a separate check-out area in the children's section! For years I've dragged screaming toddlers through the line, and watched other parents try to chase their kids while trying to check out books. Other libraries have a check-out in the children's section. It just makes sense!
Please do not make a dreadful mistake like you did at the Pittsfield branch (I don't understand why you haven't rectified this problem when so many people have complained about it). The "hands on" item that make a noise is located near the computer section and drives us crazy when both accompanied and unaccompanied children use this item as a toy to make alot of noise. Why wasn't this put near the children's section? How about taking it out and putting it in the revamped children's section of the Downtown library. While it might have been a cool "idea" to demonstrate a scientific principle, in fact it is being used as a babysitter for children who love it because of all the noise it makes. YUCK!
Please don't have a "childrens' area" where kids can run and scream. That is ridiculous. Part of growing up is learning how to behave in a library.
Please ensure that in the children's area, parents may easily supervise their children. The stacks should be kept short to allow one parent to easily supervise more than one child at a time. Also, there should be one entrance and exit to the space to eliminate the worry of a child wandering off to another area of the library unattended. The current downtown library has only one way in and out of the children's area which is wonderful. The Mallett's Creek Branch, while lovely, is less family friendly because you can't see over the stacks and children can easily wander off undetected by a parent.
Please expand programs for pre-school age children. More storytimes with music and free play.
Please keep the children's area somewhat enclosed. The trend towards wide-open spaces misses the mark for kids - they like cozy spots like the ones they already have in the current set-up.
Please make sure this does not turn into a children's drop off center for parents who don't want to deal with their children. It should also not become the place to "eat and greet" by young people or adults. It should be a comfortable, inviting reading and research center.
pls limit the kids area, unless you guys can ensure they keep the voice down. sometimes they are too noisy, which is not desirable in a library.
Quiet areas for children. There is no need for them to run wild in this quiet space.
Regarding youth, I think a fun and inviting space is important to increase awareness of the joy of reading for self improvement and entertainment. Whizz-bang stuff only interests me if it is presented as a part of a larger whole.
Safe childrens place where adults can read while children play safely.
Safe, welcoming environment for children and teens.
Seating in children's areas should accomodate multi-generational families including very young and older/disabled family members.
Security esp. high in the children's area.
Stroller accessibility, including more elevators and wide walk-ways.
Stroller accessible areas! And changing facilities for babies and toddlers, in both men's and women's rooms. Perhaps a family bathroom where Dad can take a little girl or Mom a little boy.
The children's and youth areas are big enough, but it would be nice if the spaces were designed to allow more private reading areas.
The children's area is vital to the library!!!
The children's space as is, is great - adding a preteen and teen space is more in demand - along the same lines as the kid space only at the appropriate age level with tutoring software - and group meeting places for extended learning, and group reports. Getting the A2 public school to allow the libary acess for students to use it's fast math programs and typing program that seems only acessable in the schools (they do not make it accessible for at home use, where sadly most kids and parents could utilize it more and take more part in engageing their children who need that extra time to learn properly). I'd like to see the kid space/teen space in a more secure area of the librarya, and a check in check out system. Being a public space, keeping the kids safe is high priority.
The computers in the children's room are too "in your face". I would rather the room focussed on reading and displays of books and activities that are related. Computers are nice but we have one at home. I know that not everyone does and I appreciate the games but they are very passive. I love story times and would like more interaction with books and reading.
The emphasis, at least in the children's section, is computers--the first thing you see (along w/the dvds, tapes and games along the wall). Such "noisy" and distracting items should be put in the back of the section, with the emphasis getting "back to basics"--reading!
The interactive Bernoulli display at the Pittsfield branch is extremely popular with kids. Something similar in the children's area of the main branch would be a nice touch, although the fish are very popular too!
The kids section is the most important to me. Keep the fish and puzzle/game area.
The new branches are also too loud. The Pittsfield playground takes over the library and, as a librarian, I think it subverts the purpose of the organization. Kids are important, but this is over the top.
The space allocated for younger children is adequate, but not as well used as it might be. If there were room adjacent that would be sufficient expansion. That space does not have to be "reserved" for the children all the time, though. Perhaps giving children and their activities priority during selected hours would be sufficient?
there are great children's programs offered at the downtown library and all the branches but it is very difficult to find parking and space is very tight at this events. This has discouraged me and my kids from going because its not worth the aggrivation. It would be great to address this in the design.
There should be space in the Children's area for kids to move around. There should also be space for kids to sit quietly and look at books or have books read to them. These two spaces shouldn't be next to each other (as they are right now). Please keep a large fish tank instead of something like the ball-thing at Pittsfield.
Video game magazines should not be considered children and youth anymore. I thought it was ridiculous to have to walk into the children's section to grab Nintendo Power, while a graduate student. Grabbing EGM or Gamepro from the teen section also did not feel very welcome.
We did not respond to the children's area questions as we do not have recent experience.
We use the library mostly as a place to take our 2-year-old son. I love that there's a big open space with toys that he can play with. Please consider a similar feature at the new library!
What about the 4-6th grade group. Seem to have a lot for toddlers/preschool and then for teens. Other than a few computer games, my child feels library too babyish in children's section.
When my children were small I used the library a lot and enjoyed the help of of the children's area Librarian. She helped me with suggestions for helping me with a reading problem my child was having.
When my kids were a toddler and a preschooler, I used to try to read to the preschooler and the toddler would go running off, which made it almost impossible to read a book together. I would love some kind of baby gates or other enclosed space so that a parent can pay attention to another child without having a toddler go running away.
when the downtown library added the computers to the children's area my kids were more interested in the computers than the books. I think the focus for children should be the books, not the computers.
While planning for adult usage for the library is important most adults who use the library are already patrons and will continue to visit. I fell the library should get the interest of children and preteens so that they too, develop the same love of reading and research, etc. The library also provides a safe environment for kids and teens to meet.
Teen Behavior (4 responses)
I also want to mention that I was disturbed by disrespectful teenage behavior more than several times while using the computers. Something to alieviate that problem would be beneficial.
I think there is an issue in the teen section of loud teens disrupting the harmony of other teens that are there to look at books, do homework, etc. It would beneficial to have a social room designated for those teens.
The teens just don't seem to respect the library space, so I'm not all that keen on creating a larger area for that customer group.
Improve Teen Space and Programs (25 responses)
"
Attractive areas with good supervision for teens to socialize and quiet areas for teens to work with one another or tutors. Increase diversity of programing for teens."
"
This next suggestion is not related to the new building but with new thoughts to encourage our youth to use the library. I think it will be a great idea for having areas where kids 7th grade onwards can work for experience and and get Library Points which they can then use in lieu of late fee or can use towards buying used books from the library or other such offers."
Any survey of users should include some unpublicized user counts of programs. My obeservation of the downtown library is that there is a very large population of users with younger children but less use by teens. This may be because they are more inclined to access information using the internet. Could middle school and high school users complete a survey during school hours that would be targeted to their specific needs?
As a teenager, I think that having adequate space for teens is important, but also, the Neutral Zone exists as such a space. Perhaps a partnership could be developed (or expanded?) between the AADL and the NZ.
Being a teen myself, I think that there should defenitly be more of a teen space. The funky furniture is awesome, but there should be more. An outside reading area would be wonderful, and a full service café would be really handy. At least more than the vending machines now.
I am all for teens and youth reading more, but I fear that expanding those areas will only mean a larger selection of crummy "teen" novels and nearly pornographic magazines.
I believe that the children's area is already great and needs little. I think that there is a programming gap from 7-12 year olds. I think the teen area would be enhanced by community partnerships with UM sports, Nuetral Zone Poetry, and the High Schools.
I have seen [street] people sleeping in the teen area -- is there a way to restrict access to make this a safer space for teens & pre-teens?
I think it is important to provide space for teens. Teens are varied, in interest and in maturity, and if you can divide the teen space to reflect those differences, it would be wonderful.
I think that most of the questions are very valuable, but I do not think that we need large teen areas. A library is there for study not a recreational area.
"I think the biggest challenge in the current library is how to arrange the teen space, since in my experience teens in the current teen space are not using the library in an appropriate way."
In general, the children's area is already very nice. The teen area is too small; ideally it should physically and conceptualy bridge the childrens and adults areas. The public use computers need to be separated from the browsing/reading/study/collections areas; too distracting and noisy. Don't need to see guys trolling for booty when I'm researching, LOL
It was already mentioned but a space for older kids/teens is really important.
Just about the teen section: most of those books are fluff and aren't worth my time. I wish there were more biographies/ books by REAL authors (e.g. G.K. Chesterton)
larger teen area with better lighting. more of a music selection. the dvds in more of a order. A cleaner building.
Larger variety of teen books.
Make it more fun for teens we liked to be entertained!
More and better advertised teen events.
Please consider having a teen area that permits loud atmosphere, but also a teen area that permits a quiet atmosphere. My children have been driven out of the teen area because of groups aggressively taking over the space reserved for teens and not permitting people to look for books. Perhaps, having a librarian present in an expanded teen section would help.
Please make the teen area a safe and comfortable place for teens to be. The current area is usually inhabited by verbally abusive and intimidating teens and young adults who make it difficult or impossible for other teens to use the space.
Possibly having a slightly larger teen section is my main concern but I think that the downtown library is already a peaceful place so any addition would be simply stunning.
seperate the teen computer area from the adults.
SEPERATE THE TEENS FROM THE CHILDREN,HAVE A TEEN ROOM WITH SUPERVSION,ALSO MONITOR ADULTS ON THE COMPUTERS AS WELL AS TEENS.(EX.PORN AND UNDER AGE CHAT ROOMS,ETC..
Since it is so close to the Neutral Zone, not sure that teen spaces are needed -- would rather see more collaboration between the two organizations to best utilize both spaces.
Teen Space is already like a playground.
The need for a larger teen area is very high. You already offer good services and collections, but now you need to provide teens space. Provide a large multi-function room like the kids space - places for quiet study, teen computers, space for videogaming, space to hang out, space to eat and have staff available to serve the teens. I always come with my family and wish there were teen staff to help find books etc. - if you have a bigger room you would be foolish not to - give them the top notch service you already provide in the kids room.
Better Access for Disabled Persons (59 responses)
"
Also - better accessibility for wheelchair users. Currently it is very difficult for someone in a wheelchair to browse the CD collection because there is not enough room to pull out the drawers while in a chair. The current ramp at the front entrance meets ADA requirements (I assume) but I have seen wheelchair users struggle to get up it. Please have an actual wheelcair user as a consultant on accessibity issues. ADA requirements are not always adequate."
"
Another thing is that the access to the library and the ability to use the computers and other areas should be as user-friendly to handicapped people of all ages and disabilities as it possibly can be. The library should be for all the people to use, not just those who can easily get around on foot."
A designated and safe area for disabled persons having taxi or ARide drop-off and pick-up
access everywhere for handicapped
Access for older adults, young kids, and people with mobility constraints.
Accessability for disabled
Accessibility for people of all ranges of abilities: sensory, motor, developmental. Not only accessibility for the physical structure of the building but have the latest in accessible technology for the computers.
Accessibility for wheelchairs and strollers. Good bathrooms. Keep the aquarium! Magazine area removed from computer area.
accessibilty for people with mobility, vision, or other limiting disabilities
Accessible for handicapped people/wheelchairs.
Although the library probably met ADA requirements, I constantly found that doorways were barely wide enough to accommodate a wheelchair, a lack of ramps at doors and not enough space to maneuver aisles. Let's build something that doesn't just satisfy the law but is usable and welcoming to all patrons.
Be sure to facilitate handicapped accessibility.
Better facilities for the visually impaired.
Close-by Handicap Access similar to existing access.
complete compliance with ADA laws
complete handicapped accessibility including staff assistance
COnsider more then lighting when it comes to special needs. The Bathrooms need to be usable for w/c and assistive device users. The aisles need to be wide enought for w/c's
Don't forget handicap accessibility!
Ease of access by the physically challenged; special computer stations for same, including those that are visually and hearing impaired.
Ease of use for handicapped and elderly individuals. I would like to see a more modern inviting design.
Easy access for handicapped persons.
easy access for those in wheelchairs both access to parking and to the library
Easy handicap access
electric "Amigo" carts for handicappers use only. They must not be taken out of the building because many places that allow this have them stolen.
Exceed minimum standards for handicap access to all areas
Full accessability for all individuals with disabilities adults and children.
Good access for handicapped people in and out of library and in the public areas of the library so they don't feel like second class citizens.
Good accessability for the handicapped.
greater accesibility
Hadicap accesbility, integrating easy Access for handicap: Incorporate into the plans Public access for everyone including handicap.
handicap access
Handicap access improvement.
handicap access in/out of building, up/down levels and in bathroom and checkout areas
handicap accessibility in all areas
Handicapped access and use is not well addressed. I do think it is necessary to have a game area for youth but they are loud and should not be next to the children's library area. I don't think I use the library as effectively as I once did. I feel this is because the electronic card catelogue is not as easy to use as a card file. One cannot find books on tape in a separate catalogue.
Handicapped accessibility.
Handicapped accessible
handicapped bathrooms and facilities
Increased handicapped access including availibility of "Amigo" type vehicles.
It is essential to consider the needs of those with disabilities. Too often, in attempting to "prettify" a parking area, planters, rock gardens, and green spaces are designed that seriously impede access. I hope you will be clever enough not to design such obstacles.
It is important that everything in a new building be fully accessible to wheelchair users-- from the width of aisles to the height of checkout desks. The elevator must function reliably, unlike the one the Downtown Library currently has. Bathrooms should have accessible stalls and enough maneuvering space for a power wheelchair to turn around; some branches currently lack this, including the new Malletts Creek Branch.
It should be state of the art in terms of barrier-free access. Consult with Ann Arbor Center for Independent Living.
Level access for wheelchair users or those with other mobility impairments . Textured walkways and other such accessibility needs for those who are blind or have low vision
Level access for wheelchair users or those with other mobility impairments. Textured walkways and other such accessibility needs for those who are blind or have low vision
Make sure it is useful for the visually impaired. Good signage, good contrast, accessible.
Make sure the library is usable by people of all abilities and disabilities.
Make sure there are universal accommodations
obviously handicap accessability!
Please be sure all services are accessible for the handicapped. We have an aging population, and anyone can meet a virus or a drunk driver and require that accomadation.
Please make the library fully accessible to patrons who use wheelchairs. Some of the bathrooms claim to be accessible but are actually too small for someone who uses a power chair. Also, the downtown library's elevators often breaks. The new library's elevator should be reliable so that patrons who use wheelchairs can access upper floors just like everyone else. Please make sure that aisles between books are wide enough for someone who uses a wheelchair to be able to move through them. Please have a check-out counter that is low enough for someone who uses a wheelchair to access. The doors to the bathrooms need to be automatic (like the front doors) so that wheelchair users can open them without needing someone else's help.
Possibly more services for the hearing impaired.
Question 5 talks about computers and technology for people of all ages. This *needs* to be inclusive of people of all **abilities** as well. Equal access to technology and information is critical for people with disabilities to be fully integrated into our society. All aspects of the library should be acessible, not just the physical buildign. This means screen readers and speech recognition, screen magnification, etc.
remember that disabled customers can't use the main library if it becomes hard to park. Ex. I can't walk very far and need a close handicap space or I have to go to a branch. The branches are nice, but not always adequate to a patron's needs.
Remember to think about the usability of the many different areas for children, adults and teens with disabilities. Often, being construction code compliant does not really address other universal design issues. You could engage the AA Center for Independent Living for ideas and suggestions!
Space that is easily accessible for persons with limited mobility. e,g. Shelves not very high up, nor extremely low down.
The library should be accessible to people of all physical abilities.
The very best possible handicap/accessible design must be included. Carefully consult with "experts" and real-life users for a realistic and practical plan that will truly and effectively serve a wide range of needs for persons with disabilties.
Wheelchair accessibility. As the population ages, universal access will become increasingly important and should be incorporated into every modern renovation/redesign plan. Consider meeting with local disability advocacy groups for consultations or advice.
wheelchair/cart/stroller access
Ensure Natural and Adequate Lighting (32 responses)
Adequate space and low lighting in microfilm reader area. Ensure that the building light fixtures and windows(if any) do not shine/glare on the reading surface.
Again, lots of natural light to minimize artificial light.
as much natural light as possible,
As much natural light coming in as possible
As much natural lighting as possible!
Full spectrum light rental for treating seasonal affective disorder.
good lighting for senior, esp. in reading areas
good natural light as well as comfortable seating with lamps
Great lighting with good lights for winter sun emulation. Thanks!
I and several people are sensitive to low CRI (color rating) florescent lighting. PLEASE check the CRI rating on bulbs you buy and make sure they are above 90. Otherwise, people like myself CANNOT use the facilities without suffering migraines. I'd love to be able to read in my library.
I'm glad that lighting is a factor and appreciate a well-lit library with natural light and windows. However, please consider how seasonal change will affect lighting - also how changes during the day will affect lighting. There are times of the day/year where you cannot see the screen of the public computers at Pittsfield at all (in certain rows). Other times, the sun shining onto the circulation desk shines directly into the eyes of patrons and staff.
it should be eye-catching yet feel peaceful. lots of natural light.
light-filled
lighting fixtures for after hours in the parking area and areas around the building.
Lighting should be "accent" type instead of the monotonous, all pervasive fluorescent fixtures that illuminate floors, ceilings and everything else in a bluish factory style ambiance. More like a house might do it.
LOTS, LOTS, LOTS of natural daylight.
make sure that there is a lot of light - no caves wanted - make sure that there is a lot of room for books, not just DVD's etc.
make sure there is plenty of nature light
More natural light (than artificial)
More natural light is definitely key.
More windows, cheerier color schemes, brighter more designed look. The Ypsi Library Whitaker Road branch is a terrific example of how vibrant and alive a public library can be simply by its design. A more welcoming space visually might inspire patrons to take better care of it - certainly would improve the "enjoyment" aspect of using the building. Especially build a lot of that visual beauty into staff/tech services areas - give them the same windows, natural lighting and art displays as in the public areas. Folks enjoy their jobs so much more (and work better) with windows, nice views and not being stuck in cubbyholes in the basement!:-)
more windows. In general, I love the current library. It serves the community so well, and has very interesting,relevant programs.
My concern is the lighting. The Flourecsent lisht is great for lower electric bills but it is not great for peoples eyes. I can see them flicker and it bothers me greatly.
Natural light good!!!! I love the Oak Valley library and wish the downtown were more like this.
Natural light makes all the difference in how inviting a space is.
Natural light throughout!
Natural Light, Table work spaces and comfy reading chairs, Computers available to search collections. All of these are important.
Natural lighting and comfy seating are important.
Open Spaces within the library with Natural Light.
plenty of natural light
Well lit around the library.
Windows, natural light
Mixed Responses on a Café Option (41 responses)
"
If you had a cafe or allowed more food than is already there on the 2nd floor, it would attract more mess and people using the library to hang out rather than using the materials. For me, a library should be for access to and use of materials, not a school or a club house. "
A café would be very cool!. Ann Arbor is noted for it's fantastic selection of books in it's huge library system- why not make it noted for cool, modern, and comfy library systems?
A coffee shop to relax and read book/newspapers
a large civic plaza and a cafe/bookstore, a la zingermans, with outdoor seating in the plaza would be great.
A vending area where children are welcome. The "cafe" on the second floor is not suitable for children right now.
Also I hope you do not build a snack bar. This is not the purpose of a library.
An indoor snack area for children would be a great help; I tried to give my children their afterschool snack once last winter near the vending machines upstairs, but it was difficult to keep them quiet enough so that I felt we weren't bothering other patrons. Ruling this out meant ruling out afterschool library visits, since there just isn't time to go home for snack AND go to the library. The problem disappears once the weather is nice enough to use the garden off the Youth room. I don't feel a need for a full-fledge cafe in the library myself, although it does seem a shame that the organization can't capture some of that revenue that's going to cafes a couple of blocks away.
Cafe space for eating with healthy and affordable choices would be appreciated.
computer stations/work tables in the cafe area so people who "work from home" have a place to work and can enjoy their coffee too :)
Eating area where people can eat food purchased elsewhere.
"Given the current economics of our state and city I think the city should spend money renovating or updating a useable space. Please don't locate the full service cafe or snack areas in the research center for the library. This is currently a very difficult situation when lunching with several kindergartens after the story time, but before going to school."
Having cafe is not such a good idea.
How much public money are you spending to compete with private vendors? (E.g., coffee shops) Why is this appropriate?
I checked the box for "full-service cafe" and for "retail", but I think a half-service cafe and newstand would be most appropriate. Perhaps I misinterpret "full-service" cafe, but I think something along the lines of the new cafe in the UM undergraduate library or what one sees at the airports (e.g., Caribou, Starbucks) would be appropriate) with seating nearby.
I don't think a cafe is needed.
I don't think the city needs another "borders" - with cafe and entertainment. I have been happy with the Library over the years and use it often.
I don't think there will be an adequate return on the rent investment by putting a full-service cafe. Please, it's downtown, people can get to any of twenty cafes in ten minutes and bring their favorite food/drink with them. THE DOWNTOWN LOCATION IS DIFFERENT FROM THE BRANCHES in the same way that downtown retail is different from suburban retail.
I have an adult sister that is in the library constantly and things like the cafe could possibly entice her to stay longer, it would not prevent her from going to the library.
I think a cafe would be more trouble than it's worth. If i want Borders/Barnes&Nobles cafe & books experience I go there. I don't need my library to be one too.
I think a designated vending/snack area would be adequate & more cost-effective than a whole cafe (no need to become Borders).
I think that the library is mainly quite wonderful, and the idea of a cafe/public art, etc. seems a bit silly to me. I understand that may be the trend in libraries, but I've been coming to the downtown library my entire life (32 years) and I think a library is a library, and doesn't have to be a shopping mall! With some minor improvements it will be up to date and fabulous.
I think the proposition of a cafe is utterly ridiculous, since Ann Arbor already has a surfeit of cafes.
I would love a cafe
if there is a cafe, should be private vendor
If you do choose to put a cafe in, please make sure it is healthy and "safe" for children with allergies (maybe all food would have ingredient labels?), children should feel safe at the library.
I'm not sold on a cafe, but if it was on a green roof, had outdoor space, and some evening hours, it would be a nice alternative.
Include space for eating foods brought from home. I wouldn't purchase from the cafe, but I would like to be able to feed my small children a snack.
Instead of a full-service cafe, a place indoors to sit and eat a picnic or vending snack, similar to pittsfield that is somewhat close to the youth area. This is important for parents with kids. Also, I would support a gift shop if the purpose was to raise money, not just to purchase stuff.
Instead of a full-service cafe, how about a space that's big enough for patrons to eat a little something that they bring, themselves. My family and I are always squeezed out of the tiny eating area downtown. At the Pittsfield branch, the small eating area is great.
Keep food any food areas well away from book and study areas to discourage bringing food in those areas.
Keep it non-commercial (ie if you add a cafe, it should not have a 'brand' name).
"no cafe please, competes with local business and is a distraction. this is not a Border's, etc"
No cafe. People who want a coffee shop reading atmosphere can take a few steps up the road to a cafe, or have that atmosphere at Borders. There are plenty of food places around the library. A cafe would bring noise and traffic to the library that normally wouldn't come. A place for reading, learning, and art should be the emphasis. Same goes for the bookshop.
no food "in" the library, i.e. provide a cafe space but please do not allow pop, candy, etc. in the book area
no-- just don't put anything in that's found commonly in other places-- a cafe, or art. it's wasted tax dollars that should go to more books or maybe a bigger library.
Not a full-service cafe either but definitely a snack area with vending machines with healthy options for snacks and beverages.
Please, no cafe in the library--there are plenty of places to get food downtown!
Quick affordable place to eat or drink that is clean and welcoming.
Retail/Cafe space would hurt an already ailing downtown commercial sector.
Stay away from coffeehouse environment, and put the funds into organization and efficiency, and ease of use
The Downtown Library has been a wonderful resource for my family and I'm looking forward to the renovation. Please don't put in a cafe though! We need someplace in Ann Arbor where people aren't drinking coffee.
To strongly consider the addition of a cafe (vending machines do NOT count), and make the library a place for people to meet, work, and play instead of them seeing other cafes as a more relaxing and enjoyable alternative to the library.
"I, personally, do not think food should be available in the library."
Entry Ideas/Input (25 responses)
I'd like the front desk to be more visible from the front door and a defined area where people can queue up.
"
Entrance on William would be nice -- now that the bus depot has moved Williams is more convenient than 5th."
A building that opens up to the surrounding streets would be nice.
A much more inviting entry with clear direction.
A specific area where people can congregate outside the building, that isn't the main entrance (where people entering might feel intimidated by the people and not enter).
A welcoming entrance, with good directional signage to areas within the building.
At the front entrance, if you sit down to wait for a ride, security makes you leave! This is most inconvenient when you're waiting on a taxi or someone else to pick you up. There should be a couple of benches outside for people waiting for a lift -- not everyone hanging out outside is just loitering!!
Celebrate main entrance to the library.
Clear reception area. Employees on hand to answer questions.
easy pedestrian access
effective interior signage
entrance from underground parking
Entrance off of William Street.
Exterior of the library needs to integrate into the physical fabric of the surrounding downtown. Incorporating commercial space in the first floor of the Library, with sidewalk and interior entrances will help enliven the block and keep the space "live" after Library hours.
Good access by bus, bicycle, and foot.
good pedestrian integration, as well as parking accessibility. Right now, the library is only "open" on part of one side. It should be more inviting to approach.
I hope there will still be a pedestrian entrance on Fifth Avenue!
If the building is going to occupy more space on a lot/corner than the current library, more than one street entrance would be nice, especially if a drop-off lane (for books or passengers) is being considered.
Is there a way to make the entry less appealing to people who want to hang out and smoke? As appealing as the existing large outdoor covered entry is, it's too difficult to patrol and forces patrons to walk directly past the smokers. I think a very small covered entry is the max. and you could have a larger interior space for people to stand out of weather while waiting for rides. Thank you.
It is getting better, but the cloud of cigarette smoke I would have to walk through to get to the front door is a problem.
It should be possible to tell from the street whether the library is open without having to get out of the car.
Regarding the entrance to the library: I would propose an entrance not located on 5th or William for that matter. There are always so many little children around that an entrance off the busy streets would be helpful.
The building should be very visible and very easily accessible from the pedestrian corridor (Liberty); it should draw people to it. This refers to both the exterior and the pedestrian experience getting to the library. Walking thru a parking lot can be dangerous.
The current entrance is uninspired and insufficient. It does not meet the needs of disabled and able bodied users equally, does not create a sense of entry or transition, and is an overall detriment to the library experience. Focus should be placed on improving the entry sequence.
The current setup with the checkout near the door so they can act as greeter/help seems to work well.
Mixed Input on Meeting and Performance Space (53 responses)
Lastly, I have been disturbed that a community member must *pay* to use the library's main meeting space for community meetings (unless the library itself backs the meeting). If larger performance spaces are put in, I hope they will also be open to the community for *free* for planning community events.
The meeting rooms should be State of the Art A/V equipped (including teleconferencing). For rent or free to non-profit organizations.
"
Community meeting space, and public gathering space is really, really important. I'm glad you are considering it."
"
Really would appreciate small conference rooms were, again, work from home people can go to concentrate separate from the main hub bub of library users - this space would not need to be a ""quiet"" room but would allow limited, low-tone conversations. "
Adding leasable reatial space(which leasees would be approved by the board). This will also generate revenue and in case of the need for expantion, the contrats will state this.
Affordable business meeting spaces and small presentation/meeting venues. Color printing services. Advanced/specialty software training. (Photoshop, AutoCAD, etc.)
As a staff member at a local non-profit, free and inexpensive community space, including performance space, is a great need of ours. If you do have a larger performance space, I would like to help develop policies about how it can be used by the general public.
But a nice room where seniors and children could do joint projects (see the kinds of things the Brits did with their Common Ground project, or that the Scandinavians arrange for after school interactions.....
Consider the various options for holding public events in this area. This is a very nice location, far enough away from the Hill Auditorium location to provide space for more local, artistic ventures.
don't replicate other community services, partner with them and complement them.
Have access for local and touring art groups (performance space)
Having a public performance space is badly needed in Ann Arbor. I do theater and am well aware that people are in need of venues to perform. I like your interest in a variety of possible types of rooms, as well, from small conference spaces to larger ones.
I also think that Ann Arbor has very little (none?) available low cost meeting space for community and political organizations. This ought to be a City responsibility, but this city's government is unlikely to provide it. It would be wonderful if the Public Library would step up.
I do not perceive a need for new performance spaces in downtown Ann Arbor. There are numerous theaters and other venues which adequately meet that need.
I DON'T LIKE MEETING IN THE BASEMENT. GROUND-LEVEL MEETING ROOMS WOULD BE APPRECIATED.
I have no oppinion on the meeting areas, as I have never used them. The kids' area is already quite nice.
I love attending library special events, but usually end up relegated to an outside room with closed circuit tv or audio. Improving the library for these events would be my 1st priority.
I really don't see the need for a 400 seat performance site. There are other sites downtown that serve this purpose.
I think that having a community arts and performance center would be the greatest addition to the library. Presenting art and performance through local education would draw a great sense of positive notice in ann arbor. Maybe even a food thing. seiriously, look at how big food network is and the old homemaking/doing what your mother says so you can grow into an adult thing. It's the whole challenge of growing up and living. anyhow, i just thought food classes would be sweet. learn about culture, ethnicity, and just good eating. food is life.
I think that having a stage with an auditorium that could be inexpensively leased to school, church and dance or theater groups would be fabulous!
I think that the idea of incorporating a large auditorium into the space is wonderful. Ann Arbor is a vibrant place and the AADL seems to attract lots of fascinating speakers/performers. Great job with the planning!
I used to live in a small apt. in a house right across the street from the library. The library was our "living room." Now I live some miles away and do drive downtown about 3-4times/ month. We use several libraries downtown and branches. I think you need to update the library a bit and keep it is good shape, but no need to go overboard. We have lots of nice satellite branches to choose from too. As a volunteer with an active 100% volunteer run nonprofit, I know that we often need meeting space and cannot afford to pay. I would certainly appreciate more accessible community spaces. We need a larger meeting space than your free room, and occasional space for small trainings (several classrooms at once) The auditorium idea is lovely, but the schools all have auditoriums...
I would put the public auditorium lower on the list than workstations, tutor rooms etc. If AA needs a public auditorium the City should build it.
If ya gotta build something, then the community & public art stuff above. I really wish I could've gotten a private tutoring room when I was with washtenaw literacy---my client did *NOT* like being in the children's area (personal dignity v. important to foreign learners) plus it was noisy. As a resident of a2, the library was not serving her needs, at all
If you design a large auditorium space, I think you should make it available for lease to local theater groups. This may become less of a need once the new High School opens - but it would be useful for community theater groups and private schools.
In question no 4, Couldn't the "large public performance space" also be the "large community meeting room" ?
Inexpensive, or better yet free, meeting rooms for 30 people, for non-profit groups to reserve/ schedule, especially in the evening, would be terrific.
Is there a reason that the library should have a 400 person performance auditorium? Is this the mission of the "library"?
It seems like the residents of Ann Arbor already have access to some of these things, such as performance spaces and art museums. It may be better to focus on building things which are more scarce around the town and will be equally beneficial to the residents. Great ideas, thank you!
It would be delightful to have free/low-cost meeting space available for community use. I'm imagining being able to come to the library for a rec & ed class on computers, or a lecture series, or to have neutral book-group meeting space that is sound proof enough to allow for lively conversation.
It would be wonderful to be able to reserve tutoring rooms.
Meeting space! Meeting space! Meeting space!
Please get a piano for the public performance space!
Reading room for magazines, a bright, quiet study hall. Music library.
Regarding large meeting and performance spaces. Ann Arbor has an exces of such spaces presently, particularly with UM offering many spaces for rental. the public would not recoup the value of such investments if they would not be heavily utilized, even if fees are charged. A similar argument holds for Cafe space. The town is saturated with Cafe's presently. A less expensive choice might be a food-permitted lounge area on the entry floor where people could bring their own food. Or perhaps allow a concession contractor so food service can occur without expense to the AADL? The concession could be offered to an Ann Arbor based cafe business, so the food service would have more of the home town feel that contractors like aramark can notprovide.
small theatre space for showing DVDs from the collection that can be reserved by library patrons when not being used for other purposes
Some meeting space that allows food
Some of the proposed functions seem to me to be beyond what I imagine a Library to be.Do public meeting spaces really belong in a library. Why not use space in that ridiculous new high school.
Some space por going in group to we cant talk about something.(proyect, school whiht other parents,etc).
Some space that can be used for school groups to perform in, as opposed to a larger space for much larger groups.
The "up to 400 seat" auditorium seems far too small. Current library programming routinely draws crowds near or exceeding 400 persons, with local and/or B-list events such as the Yarn Harlot and Harry and the Potters. If the new Downtown Branch is to meet the needs of our community for decades to come a arger auditorium seems justified. If AADL were to build an 1100 seat auditorium, the library could host A-list events and speakers: independent directors could premiere films, nationally and internationally recognized figures could present, and musicians could perform. The space would also expand the pool of potential renters for conferences and other non-library sponsored events, adding an additional revenue source. While serving the needs of the residents of AA should be a priority, I think that the AADL Events Center should be a Michigan venue, if not a Midwestern venue. It should draw people into our city from the rest of the state, people who will then patronize local shops, restaurants, and hotels.
The down town needs a "meeting hub. I think the downtown library could and should serve this function.
the downtown library is not a dinosaur. it meets many needs. from my point of view, the most chronically evident problem is not having a large enough public meeting space for some programs. many of the above criteria would be 'frosting' on a basically good cake. in challenging economic times, a somewhat renovated library should be pursued.
The library could offer community groups a place to display posters/flyers for their events. Commercial locations for these have all but disappeared and it is one of the best ways to reach the public. The website could also offer space for this type of information or links to these groups.
The one shortcoming I do notice is that the largest public meeting space downstairs has often been too small for events I have attended.
The variety of meeting areas within the library needs to continue to be a part of the renovation/redesign.
WE already have MANY large auditoriums in our community. I do not think this should be a priority. There are already many coffee shops and cafes. we do not need this at our library. The childrens area is wonderful as it is currently. It is so large and bright and nice. no improvements needed. The teen area could be bigger. The CD/DVDs could have their own special section with better labeling.
We are frequent users of the downtown library even through we are much closer to the Mallett's Creek branch; the bottom line is though Mallett's is a lovely place, it doesn't have the facilities we want to access. I think the library would pull more people in if it did offer better public meeting/ conference facilities. As it is, school board meetings, etc. are SRO. Also, when designing to incorporate art, it would be nice to keep in mind that art gets old and taken for granted; it is more interesting if it can be rotated on/off view occasionally.
We do NOT need an auditoridum for 400. We have them in many schools and should b e using those facilities. DO NOT NEED a cafe!
We don't need an auditorium for 400 people in terms of space usage; it would clog parking and is not in keeping with the library's purpose. But smaller tutor or classrooms could be good for teachers who want to give their students a way to meet during off school times or presenters with an approved message.
We have participated in summer reading club as well as many special events that required a large space to accommodate many people i.e. Dr. Seuss' birthday party and there was hardly enough room to sit much less move anywhere. A large room to accommodate perhaps a 1,000 as opposed a few hundred is in order.
What are opportunity costs of 400-person auditorium? Gift shop/cafe only if it can make money.
Why is the question of "public performance space" inextricably included with "state of the art"? I don't think state of the art is needed (at least in a case -- as I think this is -- where the resources will inevitably be limited, and stretched), there are other places in town for such stuff.
Would love to see a room dedicated to showing movies. We have seen several movies at the downtown building, and none of the rooms used seem designed for it.
Technology Needs/Input (77 responses)
A three-D lab in which children AND adults could experience and experiment with unusual objects in a virtual multi-dimensional world. Wall-mounted computer screens showing real-time web-cam views from all over the world. An in-library GPS system; as kids come into the library with their parents, for example, they can take a numbered bracelet/GPS unit; parents will know where their kids are; kids will know where their friends are; the kids will have fun learning about GPS.
Free public wireless access for laptop users.
Perhaps a wing dedicated to new technology (ie, computers, computer classes, and other electronic media) could be developed, since that is a new and developing library function which was probably not planned for in the original library design
A large number of computer kiosks for searching books in AADL as well as other local libaries. Access to books at other local university libraries on a short term loan basis.
A really strong presence on the web. I like what we have but it is important to keep up on new services there. Samples of new items available to check-out - new CDs or promoting "under-utilized resources" - a sort of "did you know that the library..." Some people may need a little help thinking outside the box. There are probably some things that the library has invested in that people don't seem to be using as much as anticipated.
A semi-permanent computer user assistant. Regularly accesible tutors on basic subjects.
ability to use my ipod for e books downloads
Actually, one of the most important things that isn't listed here is the number of outlets for laptops and computers. Making sure that there are more outlets (there are hardly enough anywhere in the downtown branch) and that the outlets are in pleasant places to work.
Also the library's web-based services need to be upgraded- the current system looks very nice and has great options. But it is often very slow. For all the money spent on the upgrade a few years ago the connection speeds (from one site to the next inside the library's website) are often ridiculously slow.
Although I said I agreed strongly to download stations for music, videos, I have no idea what these are.
Anything the library can do to help kids and seniors get comfortable with technology is important. It's the future!
As computer needs become more varied, each station should be able to do a wide variety of things--ie download, burn CDs,DVDs, make PDFs, work with photos, etc.
Better computer system is needed.
Better places to plug in your laptop, so that other won't trip on the cord.
Comfortable short-term previewing and listening dtations for a/v materials, perhaps via Library's catalog so even items that are not available might be previewed.
Computers need sound. The Ypsilanti Public Library offers headphones on all its computers.
Computers not for downloading, but for searching book reviews etc.
Continue to upgrade the web access to the library. A fifth option should be "Not Applicable"
Decent internet connection, because the one you have now kinda sucks. I'd focus on that instead of ridiculous crap that no one needs (a gift store?! it's a library. come on. i guess it is an interesting idea. but still -- you are first and foremost a library, how about you worry about stocking books, music, and movies for people to check out? it doesn't need to be a freaking community center. it's fine the way it is right now, save for the continual construction inside... quit tearing things apart, it's getting annoying and has made me stop coming there.)
Diversity in languages of collections. Multiple languages capability in IT/computers.
Email access
Faster computers
Filters on computers so no porn can be accessed!!
Foreward looking planning for future technology.
Free Wireless Internet access should be offered to ease public machine congestion
Free wireless internet access.
Free Wireless Internet. Public
get with the latest technology for books on cds, have ipod downloads instead of loaning out the book/cds. lthat might increase your available books. right now your books on cd is limited and basically crappy.
i don't think that everyone that doesn't pay property taxes like i do should have free use of the computers. i think there should be a fee, or fewer computers.
I feel strongly that the library should provide access to the internet and materials available on the internet. As more and more content, songs, journals, newspapers, movies, books become available on the internet, I feel it wise and important to provide public access to these to citizens of all means and abilities. To me this means the library should provide additional computers, high bandwidth access to the internet, and pay for subscriptions to online publications and services.
"I have a computer at home but I think people need more computer literacy and the library can help community members with that especially for people searching for jobs and those with less privilege than many of the Ann Arbor patrons.That's why a computer make sense--also for the elderly. "
I noticed that there are very few areas for lap top use. More plugs and private rooms would be great!
I really think it is imprtant to have more dedicated quiet areas with computer/internet access. Right now there is limitted access to internet if you really need to wk on a project from the library. That is a limitation.
I think it is important to install wireless internet in the library if it is not already in place. But laptops should only be allowed in a specific area as typing might disturb people who are reading books.
I think it would be nice to have more computers and especially ones that can use flash drives. Also, maybe it would be nice to have a bigger foreign language book collection.
I think that the best way to improve would be to offer more computers with a better internet server. The current server is slow, will not download attachments (and as I do a lot of my U of M homework @ the library, this is very inconvenient) and certain sight such as google and gmail will sometimes not work at all. All in all, updated computers would be ideal, but I hope that the library continues to focus on a cultured environment for families.
I think the downtown library is fine as it is, EXCEPT the public computer area could be vastly improved and the computers need to be upgraded. If a renovation happens, please do NOT install any 'interactive' children's exhibit in any section of the library where it will disturb adults. The one at the Pittsfield Branch is noisy and is very, extremely, completely annoying. The Pittsfield Branch is very near my home, but I rarely go because there are no "warm" or comfortable spaces. The steel and burnished concrete give it a cold, hard, industrial feel. It is not a welcoming place to browse and read.
I would like to boot my own software.
I would like to see more computers available for searching for materials within the library. Such computers can be very difficult to find. It would also be nice to have a better indexed search system online and in the library.
If some of the outdoor area or green space still picks up the libraries wi-fi, that would be a plus. It's funny to see people camped out with their laptops on the railing of the platers across from the old (former) YMCA
Improved wireless access!!
In what ways could changes in media technology over the life of this building invalidate the usage extrapolations you've made?
Increased emphasis on electronic media, both on and off-site. Staying on the cutting edge of media access options as technology evolves (e.g., exploration of licensed, time-limited downloading of copyrighted materials in electronic media form, in lieu of hard copy materials -- not sure how this would work, but may be cost-competitive with the expense of physical storage space).
It is important to realize the furture, the internet is a big plus for us. I hope that we can keep the library as current as the people needs.
It would be great to have access to color printers.
maybe a "mini Kinko's" - self-serve office center for a user fee; computers adapted for the disabled, e.g., touch screen, audio
More computers
More high tech
MUCH more spacious computing area -- it's a been like a cattle shed in there now.
music listening stations and video watching stations with good headphones
New book and CD lists and description available on the website and availability at any given time
Oh, and don't forget robust wireless access for all. It wasn't listed in the technology section, so I assume that it is a given?
Project ahead 25 years when many of the space-consuming books will be available on line or microchip and plan for more technology accomodation vs. shelves except for archived originals/ classics / tabletop editions / larger format treasures
Redesign for electronic media, less for physical books. Better access to librarians to help with database searches, how to use the resources, etc. Large screens (24"+) and readers for scanned media.
Regarding technology, I don't want the downtown library to be all about the Internet. I have that at home and don't need to go downtown for that. I want the good stuff. The library currently places too high a priority on making computers and the internet available to the public.
short-term listening station to pre-screen CD's before check-out
Significant numbers of electrical outlets and network cable connections for laptop users. Closed off "talking areas" for people that but need to make the occasional phone call or conference call.
The current computer system is horrible. The programming is not user friendly, there isnt enough room on the shelf to move the mouse around, the mouse often does not work effectively you have to keep moving it to get it to do the right thing on the screen. The older computer programming was much more user friendly. Dont make these systems too complex and inconvenient for the whole age population to be able to use them. I have been using computers for fifteen years in my work and personal life, and this system is one of the most frustrating I've ever used.
The download stations will soon become a hub for high-speed piracy. Beware.
The library was built for the computer age; what it lacks is only more stations for quick internet access: perhaps standing or seated 5-minute stations are in order; or a time limit could be installed on computers, which might save the need to replace EACH computer in the second-floor lab. (They certainly do need to be upgraded, as they are very slow.) For these reasons, a new building is unnecessary!
The library's ability to provide computer access for those who don't have it is a crucial public service.
The speed of the Internet should be speed up. With the personal laptops popular, I think the amount of public computers increased are not more important than the update Internet wireless equipments.
This is a topic that you've already listed, namely, computing facilities. At present, there are too few computers available on days and times of high usage. AADL needs both IBM-type PC's and Mac OS X computers, running up-to-date operating systems, and with faster performance.
tired of west branch closing off computers for classes--they should all be downtown--
Ubiquitous and conveniently located electric outlets and wireless access for laptops. Outlets located on/below/on side of tables are better to avoid having to lay power cords across the floor.
upgrade the computer system so that it runs faster. upgrade the software to more current versions. add some sort of scanning device for slides, pictures & text etc to be integrated into the computer system
Various ways of looking up books and media on the computer so that patrons don't have to guess the logic under which items are filed. For instance, if I want a list of all Agatha Christie videos that the library carries, I shouldn't have to search separately TV series and movies and dramas, etc. to get a list of all. I should just be able to type in Agatha Christie and get a full list with appropriate call numbers. Knowledgeable and courteous staff that can help with requests like the above.
Well-integrated, well-designed website. I primarily reserve items via the website and pick-up/drop-off items at the downtown branch. The AADL website is an important interface and could be improved as well.
wi-fi access for people with laptops
Wi-Fi, since the library is becoming more and more a space of learning and information retrieval. Reference desk people's role will turn to helping people tease out what's valid and what isn't on the web. Is the library a learning space? A cultural space? A social space? It's probably all of that and more, so the architecture needs to reflect that. Also, when building the new building please use not only sustainable but also non-toxic building materials using the EU standards for both. That will greatly affect the indoor air quality and the health of all the patrons, now and for years to come.
Wireless access for people that want to bring their laptop computers and use a quiet area to work or do research, but using his own laptop. In that way, people could communicate with their company's network through vpn but using wireless access from the library. They would have access to research material to finish a particular project (marketing, technical research) they could be working on.
Wireless internet throughout the building
Wireless internet very important.
Wireless internet.
wireless work stations where we can use programs from the library and access online resources here. like downloading media onsite and have it expire after a week on our computers
Would like a space for previewing videos (dvds and vhs).
yes. More computer terminals with faster service. Better software. Some computers in dedicated teen areas for group interaction AND a separate Quiet area for people who desire quiet while using the computers. Also a third separate computer area for parent/ child or adult group work.
You should provide a seperate room for personal laptop computer usage with electric plug-in and wireless internet access
Yourinternetsystemsisvery,very,verybadasevidencedbytheabsenceofspacesinthisnote.
Provide Larger, Clean Rest Rooms (56 responses)
*Better bathroom access for adults with kids (other than in the children's section which is fine)
1. More (women's) restrooms, and another sort of security so there could be a door to the restroom. 2. "Airport" style lockers; get your quarter back when you return your key.
accessible bathroom. more use of natural solar power to generate the library. safe and clean water fountain. more accessible for older people and handicap people.
Adequate and easy to keep clean restrooms.
Adequate bathroom facilities that are well maintained and ADA accessible.
adequate bathrooms to match increased use. Library is community center now as well as books and records.
Adequate bathrooms.
Adequate public restrooms / warming area for those who just want to stop in for a break.
Bathroom at every floor.
Bathrooms could use upgrade.
Bathrooms, making sure that they are easy to find, adequate number of stalls, clean. Having enough water fountains.
Better lavatories/restrooms.
Better restroom facilities
Bigger bathrooms or more of them.
bigger restrooms
Can you do something about the rest rooms?
Clean bathrooms
clean bathrooms
Clean bathrooms. Bathrooms dedicated to just children and families--that do not have an odor.
Clean safe restrooms where a stroller can fit. Easier options in restrooms for moms with kids.
Conveniently located re